When fear rules…
By Mike Balzotti
…Stock markets crash, real estate values plunge. A self-fulfilling prophecy runs it’s course. For sure there are very real factors in the local, national and international markets that are cause for serious concern. In today’s real estate market a major correction in the post 2005 real estate boom is well underway. It is reinforced by the near collapse of credit markets where wholesale restructuring of a system run amuck will surely grab headlines for some time to come.
In listening to the experts in portfolio management the word is don’t panic. Panic selling will only guarantee that you’ll lose even more. Why? Because by cashing in your chips for fear of greater losses you’ll miss the inevitable pendulum swing back up. Savvy financial advisors site the historical ebb and flow of bull and bear markets, where sharp loses are inevitably followed by sharp gains. It is nearly impossible to second-guess the highs and lows—invariably, by the time you know which side of the equation you’re on, it’s too late. You missed it. The winning formula is staying the coarse with proper diversification, or so the experts say.
In real estate we see much the same dynamics. The feeding frenzy of 2005 was in hindsight the top of the market. However in 2006 and 2007, even as inventories of available homes began to skyrocket, sellers kept asking higher and higher prices. This resulted in buyers holding back until the perception fully shifted to a ‘buyers market’. The point is that the shear weight of unsold and rising inventory with fewer and fewer sales foretold that prices would have to adjust. And adjust they did and are.
Now what? Like the stock market, the crystal ball is murky and no one can predict when and where ‘the bottom’ will be. However, we can site predictive trends. An emerging trend is that as home price have fallen, bargain hunters have come into the market and reversed slumping sales. In fact we see that sales have been trending up all year, tracking at about 2001 / 2002 levels (record years at the time). This inverse relationship between prices softening and sales increasing suggests a time of equilibrium in the not too distant future.
The equivalent of having a balanced stock investment portfolio in real estate is to buy location and buy long term. Historically the better locations hold value and appreciate better over time. The aforementioned leading indicator of the increasing pace of sales relative to the amount of inventory is something you can look at in specific markets and price points. In other words, when comparing similar properties in different locations, the shorter the average days on market at any given price point, the better the prospects for both buyers and sellers over time.
As to whether right now is the right time for YOU to buy (or sell) there can be no knee-jerk answer. Everyone’s situation is unique. However, the general rule is, again, like the stock market, history would strongly suggest you can buy with confidence if it’s at least a 3 to 5 year decision. History does tend to repeat itself.
Case in point—over the last 20 years we have seen real estate values increase an average of about 5% per year. The costs of purchasing and selling are about 10%. So, it takes at least 3 years of average appreciation to build additional equity even in ‘normal’ times. As to the question of whether buying now in a soft market may only see home values continue to erode, this is yet another reason why a buyer should be thinking it’s at least 3 to 5 year decision, maybe longer.
However, in spite of the downside risk, there are other compensating benefits to purchasing in today’s market—terrific selection, soft prices and historically low interest rates. For example, for every 1 percent increase in interest rates on an 80% mortgage, the effective cost of the property goes up about 8%. This is because of what the difference in payment would amortize.
Bottom line, fear need not rule. If you have a desire or need to purchase a home and plan on being in that home for at least several years you may well look back with that 20-20 hindsight and pat yourself on the back for making a very timely decision. On the other hand, if you are not in a position to stay the coarse you may do well sitting out this ‘correction’.

Recent Comments